After Hours Auto Insurance Quote Line
(4:30 PM – 8:30 PM – Monday through Friday):

1-800-892-1687

After-Hours Claim/Emergency Numbers

If you need to report a new after-hours or emergency claim, use the following contact phone numbers below:

  • The Andover Companies: 1-800-225-0770
  • ARI Insurance Companies: 1-800-820-4506
  • Farmers Insurance Company of Flemington: 1-800-842-5032
  • FMI Insurance: 1-800-842-0551
  • Foremost Insurance Group: 1-800-527-3907
  • Merchants Insurance: 1-800-462-1077
  • Mercury Insurance: 1-800-987-6000
  • NJ Skylands Insurance: 1-866-279-7688
  • Palisades Insurance: 1-888-725-9006
  • Plymouth Rock Assurance: 1-877-725-6423
  • Progressive Insurance: 1-877-776-2436
  • The Providence: 1-877-763-1800
  • Selective Insurance: 1-877-348-0552
  • Travelers: 1-800-252-4633
  • Zurich Insurance: 1-800-239-4781

Staff Directory

Take this opportunity to contact our staff:

NameEmailPhone & Extension
Frank P. Licato908-757-5500
Jeff Licatojeff@licatoagency.com908-757-5500 ext 18
Jaclyn Licatojacki@licatoagency.com908-757-5500 ext 11
JR LicatoJR.licatoagency@gmail.com908-757-5500 ext 12

We are small business and personal insurance specialists working with contractors, building owners, general liability, business owner packages, group health and NJ worker’s compensation.

top